City Commission Backs Miami New Drama for Colony Theatre Café, 6-1, After Suarez Claims "Political Insiders" Tilted the Pick

City Commission Backs Miami New Drama for Colony Theatre Café, 6-1, After Suarez Claims "Political Insiders" Tilted the Pick

Illustration: Miami Beach Journal

City Commission Backs Miami New Drama for Colony Theatre Café, 6-1, After Suarez Claims "Political Insiders" Tilted the Pick

J

Journal Staff

• 7 min read

Share:

A consent-agenda item about a café lease turned into one of the sharpest exchanges of Wednesday's City Commission meeting, ending with a 6-1 vote to open negotiations with Miami New Drama for the city-owned space at 1040 Lincoln Road, and with Mayor Steven Meiner accusing Commissioner David Suarez of lobbing "political bombs" at city staff and a 36-year-old local restaurant.

Suarez cast the lone no vote on Item C2A, which authorizes the administration to negotiate with the theater company, the top-ranked of three proposers, to run the former Segafredo café attached to the Colony Theatre. Miami New Drama's operating partner would be Café Avanti, the Italian restaurant on 41st Street.

Any lease must come back to the Commission for approval.

How a consent item blew up

Commissioner Joe Magazine separated the item, saying he was troubled that a prominent Lincoln Road storefront drew only three proposals, all from Miami Beach operators, and that the process had not put enough weight on morning and daytime activity.

"I took a video. You could have rolled a bowling ball down Lincoln Road," Magazine said of a recent mid-morning visit.

Suarez went further. He said the runner-up, Sunshine Coffee, which operates on Washington Avenue at Española Way, was the obvious choice, and questioned why a theater company was in the running at all.

"No offense to the [Miami New Drama], but what do they have to do with making a coffee shop?" he said.

He then offered his own explanation for the thin field: "political insiders that are putting their thumb on this," adding, "Why go through that process if the selection is already cooked from the beginning?"

"Prove it"

Commissioner Tanya K. Bhatt called those "spurious allegations" and asked Suarez to back them up, noting the solicitation has been under the cone of silence.

"This is the very first conversation I have had with anybody about this other than my staff briefing yesterday," she said. "I know that's your theme of a lot of your recent communications now, that everybody's corrupt all the time, but could you please elaborate?"

Suarez answered that many of his colleagues are regulars at Café Avanti and that the outcome "gives the impression" that the politically connected were rewarded over a newcomer.

Meiner, who said he had not known who bid until he read the staff memo days earlier, told the room he was "getting emotional."

"To throw out these political bombs, just to get clicks about political insiders, about corruptness. Prove it. Prove it," the mayor said. "We're all accountable. Bring the evidence. Don't just say it."

He called the remarks "an insult to everyone who works for the city."

Commissioner Monica Matteo-Salinas said she never held a campaign event at Café Avanti, though her opponent did. Vice Mayor Alex Fernandez went the other way, volunteering that he held his 40th birthday and both of his victory parties there, and praised Sunshine Coffee as well. Having two local businesses compete, he said, is one of the "good problems to have."

Suarez did not back off. Just before the vote he told the dais he had asked an AI tool how many political events had been held at Café Avanti in the last couple of years, and that the answer was eight, against none at Sunshine Coffee. The mayor cut in to repeat that commissioners had not known who the bidders were.

The 60

Magazine, who said he was making no allegation of his own, pressed on one number in the evaluation scores.

The five-member committee ranked Miami New Drama first with an ordinal total of 7, against 9 for Sunshine Coffee and 13 for Taste Bakery. But the panel was split. The two outside members, the president of the SoBe West Neighborhood Association and the executive director of the Lincoln Road Business Improvement District, scored Sunshine Coffee at 90 and 91 and ranked it first. The three city staff members all ranked Miami New Drama first.

One of them, Asset Management Division Director Ozzie Dominguez, gave Sunshine Coffee a 60, the lowest score any evaluator gave any proposer by 10 points.

Dominguez, at the podium, said he had never been to Café Avanti and met its representative for the first time at the presentation.

"I did not feel that Sunshine Coffee was a good complement for the theater, based on their hours and based on the fact that they did not serve alcohol," he said.

City Manager Eric Carpenter said ordinal ranking exists so that no single evaluator's raw score can swing the result. Procurement staff said 25 parties accessed the solicitation after outreach that went beyond the usual channels. The Commission authorized the solicitation in July, after the end of a Segafredo lease that dated to 2018, and proposals were due Sept. 8.

The hours read into the record showed the gap staff was describing. Sunshine Coffee proposed 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. Monday through Wednesday and 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. Thursday through Sunday. The Miami New Drama proposal listed 11 a.m. to 11 p.m., though the theater's representatives told commissioners the plan is breakfast, lunch, dinner, and after-show service.

The theater's case

Michel Hausmann, Miami New Drama's artistic director, told commissioners the company approached Café Avanti, not the other way around, because he wanted a partner with a local following who would last.

"I want the guarantee that I'm going to have a partner for the next two decades," he said. "There is no political logic."

He and his managing director described the café as inseparable from the theater. The roughly 820-square-foot space shares storage and restrooms with the Colony, and they said Segafredo's deliveries had landed in the middle of performances. Hausmann put the company's investment in that corner of Lincoln Road at $40 million.

Jessica Fuentes of Café Avanti said she has run morning and all-day concepts elsewhere and intends a livelier, bistro-style spinoff, open in the morning and through the day. "I think that we're just known and loved," she said of the insider charge.

Commissioner Laura Dominguez backed the pairing, saying there is plenty of vacant private real estate on Lincoln Road for other concepts.

What hangs over it

The café fight did not come out of nowhere. Suarez has spent the past year challenging the terms on which the city supports its cultural institutions.

In September, he led the questioning that turned a proposed $1 sublease for Miami City Ballet into a market-rate deal, citing executive pay. He is also the sponsor of a resolution to shift part of the resort-tax arts allocation to stormwater projects beginning in fiscal year 2027, while holding funding shares for cultural anchors and youth programs. Miami New Drama is one of those anchors. That item has been deferred or not reached at meeting after meeting since December 2025. It was on Wednesday's agenda again as R7AA and, according to the agenda record, was not reached.

The café vote was not the only one Suarez lost alone on Wednesday. The Commission also passed a Meiner-sponsored resolution to replace Suarez as the city's representative on the county transportation board, with Suarez casting the only no vote.

What's next

Suarez proposed cutting the deal to a two-year trial. The proposal on the table is five years with two two-year renewal options at the city's discretion.

Under Miami New Drama's proposal, as described in the city manager's memo, the city would be paid a minimum base rent of $60,060 in the first year, or about $5,005 a month, rising 3% a year.

The city would collect more if the café does well. Annual rent would be the greater of the base rent or 7% of gross receipts, which means the percentage takes over once sales pass roughly $858,000 in the first year, a threshold that climbs to about $965,687 by year five.

The tenant would also cover operating expenses, which the city estimates at about $21,840 in the first year, post a security deposit of two months' rent, about $10,010, and pay for its own build-out and equipment, subject to city approval. All of those terms are still open to negotiation.

Carpenter cautioned against boxing in the talks. "I wouldn't want to limit it to two years because then we're going to put them in a position where they're not willing to make any kind of capital investment in the property," he said, adding that commissioners' feedback on hours and daytime activation would shape the negotiation.

Fernandez moved the item and Bhatt seconded. Suarez was the only no.

"I think we need to make way for new and upcoming businesses to really activate parts of Miami Beach that desperately need it," he said during the debate.

Miami Beach Civic Corner

Stay informed about Miami Beach government and civic affairs

Upcoming Miami Beach Meetings

Links open on an external site

Powered by miamibeachagenda.com

Stay Informed

Get local news delivered to your inbox.

Have a news tip?

Send us a tip

About Miami Beach Journal

We are dedicated to providing local news coverage for the Miami Beach community. Our mission is to inform, engage, and empower citizens through quality journalism.